Award Winning Speech

Award Winning Speech

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Cared Mentoring vs Public Advice

To be a good manager, the subtleties of mentoring vs advice is paramount. This post is about investment of time to build a great workforce and is similar in lines to my earlier post where spending time to ensure the team "gets it" instead of mere "buy-in".

Cared Mentoring
is
  1. What teachers do on one on one discussions.
  2. What managers do on one on one sessions and appraisal discussions.
  3. What Parents share with you in close moments and in various occasions.
  4. What friends come around to warn you in ecstasy and goad you to carry on when chips are down.
  5. When customers teach you their business to help you do better.
  6. When you recognize you are being comforted instead of being flattered.
Public Advice is
  1. When you address a one-size fit all approach.
  2. When you address issues on expected lines rather than taking the root cause heads on
  3. When you appear to speak to the head and heart but not to intellect and emotions.
  4. When there is a bullet and presentation rather than an impromptu speech.

I have always loved my network to be with mentors than advisers. Do you yearn for the same traits as I do ?

3 comments:

  1. I agree with you about Cared Mentoring (and that is definitely my preference) as opposed to Public Advice. If all of us could give more Cared Mentoring and a lot less Public Advice this world would be a lot more loving, forgiving, and fun.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Pam for the resonating thoughts.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Though belated I venture to pour in my thoughts on this blog. The concept of mentoring denotes offering wise counselling as opposed to tendering of advice which may be wise or not. The reason is that people who offer advice may be or may not be empathetic and they may or may not practice what they advice. On the other hand a mentor's mind set would be the other way about. Henceone should always keep in touch with MENTORS rather than on ADVISORS.

    ReplyDelete

Top Agile Blogs

License

Creative Commons License
Learning Practice by Shrinivasan.G is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-Share Alike 2.5 India License All views expressed here are my own and does not reflect that of my employer or clients or any other sources.
.